Long Island & the Hamptons, New York

Cake & Desserts

In Long Island & the Hamptons: Twelve cake and dessert vendors are listed, including ones in Amityville, Islip, Mineola and Westhampton Beach, and pricing generally lands at $7 to $18 per slice. Delivery is the local issue. A tiered cake rides badly through summer weekend traffic on Montauk Highway, so ask your baker how far east they deliver, how they time the drive, and what they charge for it. If your venue is out on the East End, a baker based nearer to it reduces the risk more than any packaging can. Sun and heat at a beach, lawn or vineyard reception soften buttercream and fondant alike, so ask where the cake will wait until it is cut and make sure that spot is shaded and cool, not the corner of a tent in afternoon sun. For Shelter Island, the ferry adds time and a second handoff. Confirm who sets up the cake, who supplies the stand and knife, and whether the venue charges a cutting fee for outside desserts.

12 listings · checked October 2026

• Anameli Bakery — Amityville · anameliny.com · (631) 532-6677
• Audrey's Fine Baked Goods — Islip · audreybakes.com · (631) 244-7288
• Bakers of All Nations — Mineola · bakersofallnations.com · (516) 294-4034
• Beach Bakery and Grand Cafe — Westhampton Beach · beachbakerycafe.com · (631) 288-6552
• Buttercooky Bakery — Floral Park · buttercookybakery.com · (516) 354-3831
• Campbell's Bakery — Brentwood · campbellsbakeryli.com · (631) 273-7959
• Dortoni Bakery and Cafe — Commack · dortonibakery.com · (516) 796-3033
• La Roma Pastry Shop — Oakdale · laromapastryshop.com · (631) 204-3092
• Leonetti Pastry Shop — North Hempstead · leonettibakery.com · (516) 625-8242
• Levain Bakery — Wainscott · levainbakery.com/pages/wainscott · (631) 604-4123
• Oh! Nuts — Cedarhurst · ohnuts.com · (516) 295-0131
• Sweet Karma Desserts — Plainview · sweetkarmadesserts.com · (516) 794-4478

Details change constantly — confirm directly before booking. Something wrong? Update or remove a listing.