Indianapolis, Indiana

Cake & Desserts

In Indianapolis: The central Indiana cake and dessert market is full-service, with buttercream, fondant, and specialty finishes all readily available. Summer humidity is the real operational risk: an outdoor dessert table in July or August is hard on buttercream, and your baker will steer you toward finishes and staging that hold up in that heat. Winter deliveries are easier for the cake itself but harder on the driver in ice — build in weather buffer. If your date falls on Indy 500 weekend or Brickyard weekend, confirm the delivery routing explicitly with the baker; several roads near the Speedway close for the events, and a cake arriving through unexpected detours in August heat is a genuine risk worth planning around rather than assuming will sort itself.

12 listings · checked September 2026

• 1823 Bakehouse — Franklin IN · 1823bakehouse.com · (317) 739-0800
• A Slice of Heaven Cakery, L.L.C — Lapel · asliceofheavencakery.com · (765) 682-4922
• Artisan Bakery and Pastries — Indianapolis · artisanbakeryinc.com · (317) 292-9324
• Blondie's Cookies — Bloomington · blondiescookies.com · (765) 628-3978
• Circle City Sweets — Indianapolis · circlecitysweets.com · (317) 632-3644
• Iced Out Cake Shoppe-CHRCTRS — Anderson IN · iced-out-cake-shoppe-and-characters-in.hub.biz · (765) 393-3820
• L.A.Sweets Coffee Creamery and Hand Made Chocolates — Lawrenceburg · lasweets.com · (812) 637-9869
• Stacco House by Mammamia — Carmel · staccohouse.com · (317) 740-0113
• Sugar Creek Barbeque Co — Nashville · sugarcreekque.com · (812) 988-5810
• The Cake Bake Shop® — Indianapolis · thecakebakeshop.com · (317) 257-2253
• The Flying Cupcake — Indianapolis · theflyingcupcakebakery.com · (317) 396-2696
• Two Sticks Bakery — Bloomington · twosticksbakery.com · (812) 668-2125

Details change constantly — confirm directly before booking. Something wrong? Update or remove a listing.